April 21, 2021

Violent Crime Is a Confiscatory Wealth Tax

“What gives urgency to debates about race in America today — and what drives the reparations movement, are two basic facts,” Walter Russell Mead writes in the Wall Street Journal.

The first, he says, is that “The median white household has a net worth of $171,000, roughly 10 times the median net worth of black households.” The second is that the gap “is essentially unchanged from the levels of 1962.” The persistence of this gap advances the case, advocates say, for racial reparations.

Like Mead, I find the case unpersuasive, and for reasons beyond those he mentions. For one thing, dollar measures of wealth, like Mead’s and like those reported annually by the Federal Reserve, can be misleading.

That’s because wealth accumulation is a lifelong process. A large majority of Americans in their 20s have zero wealth; with college loan and consumer debt, the median 20-something may have a negative net worth. This is a feature, not a bug, of a sensible economic system. We don’t want young adults to start off with significant wealth.

Most Americans accumulate wealth over a working lifetime, and wealth accumulation tends to peak between ages 55 and 64. After 65, they tend to spend it down. So one way to gauge wealth accumulation is to look at the data for people in that age group. Another is to compare the progress toward wealth accumulation those in younger age groups have made compared with that of their counterparts in the past.

Overall figures are less helpful because they include all age groups and thus include many who have not yet accumulated significant wealth. They also tend to slightly overstate the racial gap in wealth accumulation, since Blacks are on average younger than whites. They are also less likely to live in married-couple households, which tend to accumulate wealth more than households headed by the single and divorced.

But let’s assume that the white-Black wealth gap in the peak wealth-accumulation age group is basically the same 10-1 gap Mead mentions. Why should it be so great?

Most wealth is accumulated in one of two forms, residential real estate and financial instruments. In both areas, Blacks face significant difficulties in accumulating wealth.

It’s easy to understand why Blacks tend to accumulate less in financial instruments than whites: Their income tends to be significantly lower, and it takes money — money you don’t have to spend immediately on necessities — to purchase financial instruments.

As for residential real estate, despite open housing laws and the dispersion of many Blacks into non-majority-Black neighborhoods, most Black Americans still live in majority-Black neighborhoods. And those neighborhoods, to varying extents, tend to have much higher rates of violent crime than other neighborhoods.

And violent crime depresses housing values. How much? Not just marginally. The gap Mead cites — $117,000 median wealth for whites, about 10 times the $17,100 for Blacks — is not dissimilar to the gaps in housing values for similar structures in many Black neighborhoods in Detroit (to take one example) and one of its modest-income largely white suburbs, Roseville. Compare the Zillow values for Roseville in Macomb County ($119,331) to, just a couple miles away, those of the Detroit ZIP code 48234 ($27,541).

“Violence and crime are a confiscatory tax on what people would otherwise earn and accumulate over a lifetime,” I wrote in a Washington Examiner column early this month. It is a fact, tragic and regrettable, that Blacks are much more likely than non-Blacks to commit violent crimes, and that violent crime rates in heavily Black neighborhoods tend to be much higher than average. Homebuyers are simply not willing to spend as much money (and to invest as much in what may be their greatest opportunity for wealth accumulation) on houses in neighborhoods with five to 10 to 15 times the violent crime rate of many alternatives.

The sharp reduction in violent crime rates since 1990 has increased the housing values in heavily Black neighborhoods and thus increased wealth accumulation by Black Americans over that time. Further reductions in violent crime rates could go some distance to enable Black Americans to accumulate wealth and perhaps narrow the wealth gap Walter Mead describes. Increasing violent crime rates — one possible result of the Black Lives Matter protests and recent violent rioting — could have the opposite effect, as it did after the violent rioting half a century ago.

Michael Barone is a senior political analyst for the Washington Examiner, resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and longtime co-author of The Almanac of American Politics.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

21 Responses

  1. So putting whites in a worse position HELPS blacks? Strange kind of economic philosophy. If it is the crux of the problem where do all the rich blacks come from, my brother-in-law for one? He drives a Tesla and he didn’t win it in any give-a-way.

    1. Your brother in law, more than likely worked HARD for what its his. And well deserved. more power to him and the thousands of milllionaire blacks in this country! Where do you see a millionnaire black in China, in Russia? to start there are no blacks in either of these countries.! Theyre racists! or blacks are smart and dont want to go there !

  2. Like!! Really appreciate you sharing this blog post.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  3. Hello mate, I just wanted to tell you that this article was actually helpful for me. I was fortunate to take the tips you actually so kindly shared and even put it to use. Your web blog article truly aided me and i also would like to inform your dedicated audience that they really have someone that has her or his thoughts fixed. Thank you once more for the excellent posting. I’ve truly bookmarked this on my favored online bookmarking web site and i also recommend everyone else do the very same.

  4. Site owner, I may be right in saying your web server stopped functioning yesterday because I located this page through Google and all I saw was a failure page. I would email your hosting provider to ensure that it doesnt happen again as your losing visitors. I was using IE 8 browser if that helps.

  5. I appreciate you for posting such a wonderful website. Your weblog was not only informative but also very inventive too. We find very few bloggers who can create technical articles that creatively. I keep looking for information regarding something like this. We ourselves have gone through many websites to build up on information regarding this.I will keep coming back !!

  6. Hello this post is nice and interesting. I’ll use it for my project . Can you say to me some related articles that I can read too? –

  7. Im usually looking for excellent info on this topic. It can be difficult to locate sometimes. Thanks!. I will check back on your website from time to time to see what else you have to supply. http://www.xmc.pl

  8. These kind of post are always inspiring and I prefer to check out quality content so I happy to find many good point here in the post, writing is simply great, thank you for the post

  9. I am going to go ahead and save this content for my sister for a coming up study project for school. This is a appealing blog by the way. Where did you get the template for this website?

  10. Hey there I am so happy I found your web site, I really found you by mistake, while I was browsing on Google for something else, Anyways I am here now and would just like to say cheers for a incredible post and a all round entertaining blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to look over it all at the minute but I have bookmarked it and also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read much more, Please do keep up the awesome job.

  11. Hi, where did you get this info can you please support this with some proof or you may say some good reference as I and others will really appreciate

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Sign Up For The Daily Newsletter