May 17, 2022

Ticket Balancing May Be Risky for Joe Biden

If the presidential nominating process is the weakest part of our political system — and, perhaps not coincidentally, one not referenced by the founders — the vice presidential selection process comes solidly in second place. Some might even argue it’s a contender for the top spot.

That’s been particularly the case in the two most recent election cycles. The 2016 election, with Republican and Democratic nominees ages 70 and 69 on Election Day, respectively, elevated the actuarial odds of a vice president succeeding to the presidency to the highest level in history.

This year, the Republican and Democratic nominees turn 74 and 78, and the actuarial odds are accordingly grimmer. With Vice President Mike Pence sure to be re-nominated, the focus is on Joe Biden’s choice, delayed now from the promised “first week of August.”

Foreigners must consider it odd that 30 to 34 million people participate in selecting presidential nominees, but it’s taken for granted that vice presidential nominees are selected by just one person. They may also consider it odd that Biden has limited his choice to women and, apparently — he’s not quite transparent on this — to women who are nowadays called women of color. That limits the plausible picks to a very small percentage, and each of those mentioned seem to have at least one plausible disqualifying characteristic.

Former national security adviser Susan Rice, for example, with more foreign policy and national security experience than the others mentioned, was the Obama administration’s designated liar, going on five Sunday programs as U.N. ambassador in 2012 to spread a legend about Benghazi. Sen. Kamala Harris is regarded by many Democrats as having been too prosecutorial when she was district attorney in San Francisco. Rep. Karen Bass was a big fan of Fidel Castro (Florida has 29 electoral votes). Rep. Val Demings was a cop.

Looking back, the two women previously nominated for vice president, former Rep. Geraldine Ferraro and former Gov. Sarah Palin, also had thin credentials and glaring weaknesses. But both, in my view, performed better in their fall campaigns than the men who selected them were entitled to expect. Maybe Biden’s choice will, too.

And there’s historical precedent for nominees choosing from a sharply narrowed field. The Democratic Party has, from its beginnings, been a coalition of out-groups, capable of winning majorities when united.

Keeping them together, however, can be hard work. Narrowing the VP list to women, or black women, rewards two decadeslong core constituencies, feminist-minded female college graduates and blacks. The prospect of a black female vice president, especially one with a non-negligible actuarial chance of becoming president, might maximize turnout of college females and blacks.

Of course, Americans have already elected a black president and nearly elected a woman. The prospect of a black woman vice president might seem no big deal. After John F. Kennedy won the presidency with 78% of Catholic votes in 1960, Catholic VP nominees were chosen by Republicans in 1964 and by Democrats in 1968 and 1972. All three tickets lost.

Democrats have had to choose from narrow fields of VP possibilities before. In the six decades after the Civil War, when the party’s major constituencies were white Southerners and Catholic immigrants, it was considered unthinkable to put a Southerner or a Catholic on the ticket.

During these years, Democrats — and Republicans — usually nominated Northern Protestants from New York, Ohio or Indiana, the three large marginal states in close elections. A VP nominee’s local appeal, they hoped, might swing enough electoral votes to swing the election. We lack the polling evidence to indicate whether this was so.

But between 1868 and 1920, every winning ticket and most losing tickets had at least one nominee from these three states, which were the home bases of the winning VPs in 10 of 14 elections.

There’s a stronger argument for ticket balancing, at least since former President Jimmy Carter and former Vice President Walter Mondale reinvented the vice presidency as a working part of the executive branch. All but one of the vice presidents selected then had a career path and a set of experiences significantly different from those of the president who selected them.

Former Vice Presidents Walter Mondale, Dan Quayle, Al Gore, Joe Biden and Mike Pence have 12 to 36 years of congressional experience, compared with zero to four years for the presidential nominees who picked them. George H. W. Bush and Dick Cheney had years of foreign policy and national security policy experience, while the nominees who picked them had virtually none.

Joe Biden, with tons of experience (36 years in the Senate, eight in the White House), is said to be wary of an ambitious VP and may be tempted to name someone with little or no experience. Balancing the ticket that way wouldn’t be unprecedented but might be unnerving to voters with a sense of the actuarial odds.

Michael Barone is a senior political analyst for the Washington Examiner, resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and longtime co-author of The Almanac of American Politics.


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
0 0 votes
Article Rating

This is a demo advert, you can use simple text, HTML image or any Ad Service JavaScript code. If you're inserting HTML or JS code make sure editor is switched to 'Text' mode.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

alicia Cervera (@guest_1033251)
1 year ago

Bidens first promised: BROKEN!

NANCY JO EVILSIZOR (@guest_1033257)
1 year ago


Jan Schilling (@guest_1033274)
1 year ago

I shudder everyone i think of him as president…but there are always standbys to help hm with decision making. My main worry about the VP is, we know Sleepy Joe won;’t warm that Oval office chair up for the entire presidency…i give him a few months at best..then his mental disability will be glaringly unavoidable and the decision for him to step aside and let he VP take over…gives me chills in the night! AND… let’s say SHE has realized she has bit off a bigger bite of the apple then she intended, and isn’t up to the job…who do we have waiting in the wings…none other than Nancy Pelosi! OMG OMG…the horror of that is too much to put down on paper! And it could happen,
…it has before when we inherited Gerald Ford.

russell remmert (@guest_1033261)
1 year ago

biden using the vice president search as a front is ridiculous

Jon (@guest_1033264)
1 year ago

He ain’t done nothing he’s a pig with earrings all show and no go. No vision whatsoever. Boring as they come

thomas (@guest_1033278)
1 year ago

GROPER JOE WHO’S 50+ yrs of total failure

Esther (@guest_1033420)
1 year ago

I don’t think selecting a VP should be based on gender or color. Ability, knowledge, and experience should be the measurement stick. We get that Biden and the Democrats are trying to make us a communist country. I especially don’t like what Biden is doing by not revealing his choice. He acts like a little drama queen.

Wildbill (@guest_1033522)
1 year ago

When Biden disavowed the Hyde Amendment, he threw the Catholic church under the bus. Good luck with that. We vote..

WWW.XMC.PL (@guest_1116899)
1 year ago

I am really Glad i ran across this website.Added to my bookmark!Check out my Kissing Guide !

Tomasz (@guest_1116969)
1 year ago

It’s arduous to seek out educated people on this topic, but you sound like you recognize what you’re speaking about! Thanks

Pianino co to jest ? (@guest_1123433)
1 year ago

I just signed up to your blog feed after reading this post! Can you write more regarding this in future articles?

Pianino (@guest_1125343)
1 year ago

This is a fascinating article by the way. I am going to go ahead and save this post for my sister to check out later on tomorrow. Keep up the first-rate work.

Stopy Metali (@guest_1126855)
1 year ago

Miej odwage zyc. Umrzec potrafi kazdy. – Robert Cody

Socjologia Blog (@guest_1128615)
1 year ago

I really like what you posted. I really agree with what you wrote.

Japan Directory (@guest_1131134)
1 year ago

Glad to be one of several visitors on this awesome internet site Look us Website http://www.Webmaster.M106.COM Thanks!

Skandynawia (@guest_1135763)
1 year ago

Najwieksza porazka w zyciu czlowieka to rozziew pomiedzy tym, kim mlgl sie stac, a tym, kim stal sie w rzeczywistosci.- Ashley Montagu.

Filozofia Kartezjusz (@guest_1142308)
1 year ago

I was just chatting with my coworker about this today at Outback steak house. Don’t remember how in the world we landed on the topic in truth, they brought it up. I do recall eating a outstanding fruit salad with cranberries on it. I digress (@guest_1147545)
1 year ago

Im not sure why but this weblog is loading incredibly slow for me. Is anyone else having this problem or is it a issue on my end? Ill check back later on and see if the problem still exists.

Japonia.XMC.PL (@guest_1153882)
1 year ago

The Secrets and techniques of Money Gifting! Discover How I Rake in 1000s With Cashgifting

Cukrzyca Portal (@guest_1158381)
1 year ago

Resources like the one you mentioned here will be very useful to me! I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will find that very useful. (@guest_1195031)
1 year ago

My brother recommended I might like this blog. He was entirely right. This post truly made my day. You can not imagine simply how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

Podatki Portal (@guest_1204280)
1 year ago

Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that its really informative. I’m gonna watch out for brussels. I will appreciate if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

WWW Listing (@guest_1210640)
1 year ago

Thanks, I have been seeking for information about this topic for ages and yours is the best Ive discovered so far.

Ekonomia Tematy (@guest_1213785)
1 year ago

This is some reliable stuff. It took me some time to come across this site but it was worth the time. I noticed this website was buried in google and not the first spot. This internet site has a lot of respectable stuff and it doesnt deserve to be burried in the searches like that. By the way Im going to add this site to my list of favorites.



Sign Up For The Daily Newsletter


Would love your thoughts, please comment.x