August 14, 2022

Mandatory Voting Is Authoritarian

After the 2016 presidential election, I wrote an exceptionally unpopular op-ed for The Washington Post headlined, “We must weed out ignorant Americans from the electorate.” In it, I noted that “never have so many people with so little knowledge made so many consequential decisions for the rest of us.”

My assumption has always been that the Post only accepted the piece because its editors believed I was aiming my criticism exclusively at the right-wing populists who had just voted for Donald Trump. If so, they were wrong. My skepticism extends to all sides.

And to all elections. Indeed, today, the problem is even more severe. More Americans voted in 2020 than ever before even though the winner, Joe Biden, was rarely impelled to answer a substantive question on policy or even to show himself in public. 2020 might have featured the most vacuous campaigns in American history. This is what “democracy” looks like when propelled by fearmongering, ignorance and the “common impulse of passion,” as James Madison warned. I mean that all around.

We encourage Americans to vote as if it is the only right of a citizen, without any corresponding expectations. And as if that constant cultural haranguing to vote weren’t annoying enough, after every election, no matter how many people participate, there is a campaign to force everyone to do it.

“America Needs Compulsory Voting,” writes a professor in Foreign Affairs. “A Little Coercion Can Do a Lot for Democracy.” “1 In 3 Americans Didn’t Vote. Should We Force Them To Next Time?” asks BuzzFeed.

Ideally, in a free nation, the answer to “should we force them?” is almost always “no.” But for the folks at places such as the Brookings Institution and Harvard University’s Ash Center for Democratic Governance and Innovation, the answer is almost always “yes.” In July, these think tanks laid out their case for mandatory voting in a report titled “Lift Every Voice: The Urgency of Universal Civic Duty Voting.” I wish I could whip up an equally anodyne euphemism for “ugly authoritarian instinct,” but none immediately comes to mind.

None of this is new, of course. Over the years, we’ve seen similar columns in The New York Times and Time. Obama administration officials such as Peter Orszag, an advocate of compelling everyone to buy state-mandated health insurance, were arguing that the United States “prides itself as the beacon of democracy, but it’s very likely no U.S. president has ever been elected by a majority of American adults.” Maybe the lesson here is that we should pride ourselves on how many freedoms we enjoy rather than how people vote.

“The hope is not that the United States of America tomorrow morning is going to adopt this,” E. J. Dionne, who is a Georgetown University professor of government, a Washington Post columnist and a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, told BuzzFeed, “but we do hope that cities, counties, states would take a look at this and perhaps adopt it experimentally, the way, say, Maine has adopted instant runoffs.”

Some of us do not share the hopes of Dionne, a long-time proponent of forcing Americans to do all sorts of things. The Constitution makes no stipulation that citizens must vote. It doesn’t even mention voting as an individual right. We have no civic duty to vote. I haven’t voted for president since 2000. I haven’t voted at all since 2004.

For me, this is a proactive political choice. But maybe some Americans don’t vote because they are anarchists, or monarchists, or nihilists. Some Americans might not be satisfied with any of their choices. Some might rather be watching cartoons. It’s none of Dionne’s business. The last thing we should do is make those who aren’t interested, motivated or feel unprepared to make sound decisions act against their will.

Whenever I mention that compelling people to participate in the political system is authoritarian, someone will ridicule me by noting that voting is the hallmark of “democracy.” One wonders if citizens of, say, Hong Kong, who had no real vote as British colonial subjects for 150 years, feel freer today than they did 30 years ago. Sure, mandatory voting exists in Australia and Belgium. But it also exists in Bolivia, Congo, Dominican Republic, Egypt and Lebanon. In fact, historically speaking, authoritarian states often adopt compulsory voting as a way of creating a false sense of democratic legitimacy. If you’re compelling people to participate, you’re not doing “democracy.”

2020 saw record turnout — though calling it a “turnout” is a bit misleading since the involvement was largely a function of states’ haphazardly mailing out paper ballots to everyone. All mandatory-voting advocates are doing is further degrading the importance of elections and incentivizing more demagoguery. If they truly believed democracy was sacred — rather than a way to accumulate power — they’d want Americans to put more effort into voting for the president than they do in ordering Chinese takeout. And they certainly wouldn’t want to force anyone to do it.

David Harsanyi is a senior writer at National Review and the author of the book “First Freedom: A Ride Through America’s Enduring History With the Gun.” To read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate webpage at


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
0 0 votes
Article Rating

This is a demo advert, you can use simple text, HTML image or any Ad Service JavaScript code. If you're inserting HTML or JS code make sure editor is switched to 'Text' mode.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Norbert Kausen C.D. (@guest_1083919)
1 year ago

It CANNOT be made mandatory! It is everyone’s FREE right to choose to vote or NOT! If they don’t, they simply have no legitimate right to complain. IF there is a choice to vote for “NONE ON THE ABOVE”, then people may have all the choices they need! To force anyone to vote is TOTALITARIAN and TYRANNICAL!

Richard (@guest_1084144)
Reply to  Norbert Kausen C.D.
1 year ago

Free countrys do not force their will on free people. I vote because it’s my choice as a free man. Key word (Free).

Phillip W Lewis (@guest_1083924)
1 year ago

It CANNOT be made mandato…..

Frank (@guest_1083956)
1 year ago

You can’t fix Stupid and we apparently had lots of Stupid people vote this time around. If voting is mandatory, there will only be more Stupid people voting in the rigged system.

Jack (@guest_1084005)
Reply to  Frank
1 year ago


Joe (@guest_1084041)
1 year ago

They would just say everyone voted and put in whoever they wanted.

XMC (@guest_1116736)
1 year ago

It is by far no way to do it and you should avoid as much as possible. (@guest_1123382)
1 year ago

This is some enjoyable stuff. It took me a while to locate this website but it was worth the time. I noticed this page was buried in google and not the number one spot. This web site has a ton of nice stuff and it does not deserve to be burried in the search engines like that. By the way Im going to save this website to my favorites.

Pianino Producenci (@guest_1125308)
1 year ago

Thank you pertaining to sharing this kind of wonderful content material on your web-site. I discovered it on the internet. I may check back again whenever you publish extra aricles.

Metale (@guest_1126788)
1 year ago

Pielegnuj swoje marzenia. Trzymaj sie swoich idealow. Maszeruj smialo wedlug e-muzyki, ktora tylko Ty slyszysz.

Socjologia Opis (@guest_1128577)
1 year ago

Interesting information provided, have send your url to a few others

Japan Portal (@guest_1131100)
1 year ago

Boa noite companheiros, provavelmente disparar um torpedo web grátis está cada vez mais trabalhoso devido falta de opções das operadoras de telefone. Há ainda os websites que prometem entregar meu SMS mas nem sempre chegam recepiente final. Alguns como o Mundo oi e o Oi Torpedo funcionam mas e para as outras operadoras? E os que prometem que enviam e nada chega. Para onde está indo as as minhas menssagens? E para a Tim, Vivo? Alguma Idéia? Ou significa ter de desembolsar?. Foi mal, realmente está difícil achar dicas para enviar torpedos sem custo.

Norwegia (@guest_1135645)
1 year ago

Cecha talentu jest niemoznosc pisania na zamowienie… Poza tym to Zgadzam sie z Toba w 100 i popieram w/w poglady w soposb preSubiektywny 🙂 E. Zegadlowicz.

Filozofia Sokrates (@guest_1142238)
1 year ago

I must say this information was very interesting. I stumbled onto you using a google search and was rather thankful for your rank for this article.

Japonia Tokio (@guest_1153826)
1 year ago

I like that site layout ! How was it made? Its really good.

Cukrzyca (@guest_1158334)
1 year ago

Thank you for that smart critique. Me & my neighbour were preparing to do some research about that. We received a very good book on that matter from our local library and most books exactly where not as influensive as your information. Im quite glad to see this kind of information which I was searching for a long time.

Links Directory (@guest_1210575)
1 year ago

If you really want you can look the other way and not talk about it. Dont give up your morals for anything. This will lead to a sad and unfulfilling life.

Ekonomia Portal (@guest_1213741)
1 year ago

We like your post, the point that your web site is definitely a tiny bit diverse makes it so fascinating, I actually get fed up of seeing the same outdated tedious recycled stuff almost all of the time.

Javiernop (@guest_1253206)
1 year ago

what is tinder , tinder online



Sign Up For The Daily Newsletter


Would love your thoughts, please comment.x